| 2025 | NSW | QLD | Hamza Bangash - NSW | Moreton Bay |
| 2024 | NSW | QLD | Laurence Taylor – NSW | Perth |
| 2023 | NSW | QLD | Joseph Lacey - NSW | Canberra |
| 2022 | NSW | VIC | Mark Leonard - VIC | Sydney |
| 2019 | NSW | VIC | Ben Gibson - NSW | Brisbane |
| 2018 | NSW | WA | Michael Ruhs - NSW | Shepparton |
| 2017 | NSW | SA | Lachlan Sepping - NSW | Adelaide - PSG |
| 2016 | NSW | VIC | Lachlan Campbell - NSW | Perth |
| 2015 | NSW | VIC | Leonardo Malfara - NSW | Adelaide - PSG |
| 2014 | NSW | QLD | Felipe Zapato-Castro - NSW | Sydney |
| 2013 | ACT | NSW | Reece Papas - NSW | Canberra |
| 2012 | NSW | VIC | Jake McGing - NSW | Townsville |
| 2011 | NSW | QLD | Stejpan Paric - NSW | Adelaide |
| 2010 | NSW | QLD | Jack Keating - NSW | Melbourne |
| 2009 | NSW | QLD | Massimo Luongo - NSW | Perth |
| 2008 | NSW | QLD | Matthew Lewis - NSW | Port Macquarie |
| 2007 | NSW | SA | Glen Trifiro - NSW | Darwin |
| 2006 | NSW | QLD | Ben Gough - NSW | Canberra |
| 2005 | QLD | NSW | Evan Berger - NSW | Cairns |
| 2004 | NSW | WA | Semir Sivic - VIC | Adelaide |
| 2003 | NSW | SA | Michael Mouyis - NSW | Melbourne |
| 2002 | NSW | VIC | Michael Dowling - NSW & Robert Cattanach - ACT | Perth |
| 2001 | ACT | NSW | Wayne Heath - ACT | Gosford |
| 2000 | NSW | VIC | James Monie - NSW | Darwin |
| 1999 | SA | NSW | Danny Vasilevski - ACT | Canberra |
| 1998 | SA | NSW | Josh Christison - SA | Brisbane |
| 1997 | VIC | SA | Tony Czimadija - VIC | Adelaide |
| 1996 | VIC | NSW | Kain Rastall - NSW | Geelong |
| 1995 | NSW | QLD | Mark Robertson - NSW | Perth |
| 1994 | NSW | VIC | Nick Bosevski - NSW | Sydney |
| 1993 | NSW | SA | John Ghisso - NSW and Steve de Giolo - SA | Darwin |
| 1992 | QLD | VIC | Corey Artone - SA | Canberra |
| 1991 | NSW | VIC | Shane Jarvis - NSW | Brisbane |
| 1990 | NSW | QLD | Peter Tsekenis - NSW | Melbourne |
| 1989 | ACT | NSW | Cesar Mora - NSW | Adelaide |
| 1988 | NSW | ACT | David Seal - NSW and Ned Zelic - ACT | Darwin |
| 1987 | NSW | SA | David Scott - NSW and Craig Hoogendorn - ACT | Perth |
| 1986 | ACT | NSW | Robert Runje - ACT and George Jolevski - VIC | Sydney |
| 1985 | NSW | VIC | Brian Ellem - NSW | Canberra |
| 1984 | NSW | QLD | Martin Drienne - NSW | Hobart |
| 1983 | ACT | NSW | Andrew Lescynski - TAS | Brisbane |
| 1982 | NSW | Test Series: NSW v. Queensland | Brisbane | |
| 1981 | VIC | NSW | Lenny Vial - NSW | Melbourne |
| 1980 | NSW | SA | Fabian Incantalupo - VIC | Wollongong |
| 1979 | VIC | NSW | Brett Beves - NSW | Brisbane |
| 1978 | Northern NSW | VIC | Player of the Tournament award commenced in 1979 | Newcastle |
| 1977 | VIC | SA | | Adelaide |
| 1976 | Northern NSW | VIC | | Melbourne |
| 1975 | VIC | Northern NSW | | Newcastle |
| 1974 | NSW | SA | | Sydney |
| 1973 | NSW | SA | | Adelaide |
