| 2016 | Ned | Cahill | Essendon |
| 2016 | Caleb | Serong | Fremantle |
| 2015 / 2016 | Matthew | Rowell | Gold Coast |
| 2015 | Kyle | Dunkley | Melbourne |
| 2015 | Xavier | Duursma | Port Adelaide |
| 2015 | Jye | Caldwell | Greater Western Sydney |
| 2014 | Changkouth | Jiath | Hawthorn |
| 2014 | Aidan | Bonar | Greater Western Sydney |
| 2014 | Kane | Farrell | Port Adelaide |
| 2014 | Luke | Davies-Uniacke | North Melbourne |
| 2014 | Paddy | Dow | Carlton |
| 2014 | Hunter | Clark | St Kilda |
| 2014 | Lachlan | Fogarty | Geelong |
| 2014 | Lochie | O'Brien | Carlton |
| 2014 | James | Worpel | Hawthorn |
| 2014 | Cameron | Rayner | Brisbane |
| 2013 | Harry | Morrison | Hawthorn |
| 2013 | Jarrod | Berry | Brisbane |
| 2013 | Joe | Atley | Port Adelaide |
| 2013 | Alex | Witherden | Brisbane |
| 2013 | Andrew | McGrath | Essendon |
| 2013 | Ben | Ainsworth | Gold Coast |
| 2013 | Jye | Simpkin | North Melbourne |
| 2013 | Will | Brodie | Gold Coast |
| 2012 | Aidyn | Johnson | Port Adelaide |
| 2012 | Josh | Dunkley | Western Bulldogs |
| 2012 | Darcy | Parish | Essendon |
| 2012 | Josh | Schache | Brisbane / Western Bulldogs |
| 2012 | Rhys | Mathieson | Brisbane |
| 2012 | Daniel | Houston | Port Adelaide |
| 2012 | Kurt | Mutimer | West Coast |
| 2012 | Jarrod | Berry | Brisbane |
| 2011 | Angus | Brayshaw | Melbourne |
| 2011 | Patrick | McCartin | St Kilda |
| 2011 | Thomas | Lamb | West Coast Eagles |
| 2011 | Daniel | McKenzie | St Kilda |
| 2011 | Corey | Ellis | Richmond |
| 2011 | Touk | Miller | Gold Coast |
| 2011 | Peter | Wright | Gold Coast |
| 2011 | Darcy | Moore | Collingwood |
| 2011 | Hugh | Goddard | St Kilda |
| 2011 | Matthew | Goodyear | Collingwood |
| 2011 | Zaine | Cordy | Western Bulldogs |
| 2011 | Billy | Evans | Brisbane |
| 2011 | Jesse | Palmer | Port Adelaide |
| 2011 | Dan | Butler | Richmond |
| 2010 | Christian | Petracca | Melbourne |
| 2010 | Darvy | Moore | Collingwood |
| 2010 | Lewis | Taylor | Brisbane |
| 2010 | Joshua | Kelly | Greater Western Sydney |
| 2010 | Matt | Crouch | Adelaide |
| 2010 | Luke | McDonald | North Melbourne |
| 2010 | Christian | Salem | Melbourne |
| 2010 | Jack | Billings | St Kilda |
| 2010 | Nathan | Drummond | Richmond |
| 2010 | Ben | Lennon | Richmond |
| 2010 | Nathan | Wright | St Kilda |
| 2010 | Billy | Hartung | Hawthorn / North Melbourne |
| 2010 | Dallas | Willsmore | Hawthorn |
| 2009 | Jason | Ashby | Essendon |
| 2009 | Ollie | Wines | Port Adelaide |
| 2009 | Jake | Stringer | Western Bulldogs / Essendon |
| 2009 | Dylan | Buckley | Carlton / Greater Western Sydney |
| 2009 | Joe | Daniher | Essendon |
| 2009 | Nathan | Hrovat | Western Bulldogs / North Melbourne |
| 2009 | Lachie | Whitfield | Greater Western Sydney |
| 2009 | Tim | Membrey | Sydney Swans / St Kilda |
| 2009 | Kristian | Jaksch | Greater Western Sydney / Carlton |
| 2008 | Devon | Smith | Greater Western Sydney / Essendon |
| 2008 | Jackson | Paine | Collingwood / Brisbane |
| 2008 | Dylan | Shiel | Greater Western Sydney |
| 2008 | Jonathon | Patton | Greater Western Sydney / Hawthorn |
| 2008 | Thomas | Bugg | Greater Western Sydney / Melbourne |
| 2008 | Taylor | Adams | Greater Western Sydney / Collingwood |
| 2008 | Billy | Longer | Brisbane / St Kilda |
| 2008 | Michael | Talia | Western Bulldogs / Sydney Swans |
| 2008 | Tim | Golds | Greater Western Sydney |
| 2008 | Nick | O’Brien | Essendon |
| 2007 | Dion | Prestia | Gold Coast / Richmond |
| 2007 | Jake | Batchelor | Richmond |
| 2007 | Josh | Toy | Gold Coast |
| 2007 | Tom | Liberatore | Western Bulldogs |
| 2007 | Mitchell | Wallis | Western Bulldogs |
| 2007 | Matthew | Watson | Carlton |
| 2007 | Jon | Hutchins | Gold Coast |
| 2007 | Ben | Jacobs | Port Adelaide / North Melbourne |
| 2007 | Shaun | Atley | North Melbourne |
| 2007 | Piers | Flanagan | Gold Coast |
| 2007 | Luke | Mitchell | Carlton |
| 2007 | Alex | Keath | Adelaide, Western Bulldogs |
| 2006 | Steele | Sidebottom | Collingwood |
| 2006 | Jack | Ziebell | North Melbourne |
| 2006 | Jaryd | Cachia | Carlton |
| 2006 | Tom | Scully | Melbourne / Greater Western Sydney |
| 2006 | Daniel | Talia | Adelaide |
| 2006 | Andrew | Hooper | Western Bulldogs |
| 2006 | Allen | Christensen | Geelong / Brisbane |
| 2006 | John | Butcher | Port Adelaide |
| 2006 | Jordan | Gysberts | North Melbourne / Melbourne |
| 2005 | Trent | Cotchin | Richmond |
| 2005 | Scott | Selwood | West Coast / Geelong |
| 2005 | Patrick | Dangerfield | Adelaide / Geelong |
| 2005 | Jackson | Trengove | Port Adelaide / Western Bulldogs |
| 2005 | Nick | Suban | Fremantle |
| 2005 | Tom | Rockliff | Brisbane / Port Adelaide |
| 2005 | Addam | Maric | Melbourne |
| 2005 | Nick | Heyne | St Kilda |
| 2005 | Mitchell | Banner | Port Adelaide |
| 2005 | Ryan | Bastinac | North Melbourne / Brisbane |
| 2005 | Tom | Lynch | St Kilda |
| 2005 | Jordan | Jones | West Coast |
| 2005 | Ashley | Smith | West Coast |
| 2004 | Sam | Sheldon | Brisbane |
| 2004 | Matthew | Kreuzer | Carlton |
| 2004 | Ben | Reid | Collingwood |
| 2003 | Lee | Adams | North Melbourne |
| 2003 | Xavier | Ellis | Hawthorn, West Coast |
| 2003 | Shaun | Grigg | Carlton / Richmond |
| 2003 | Bacher | Houli | Essendon / Richmond |
| 2003 | Nathan | Jones | Melbourne |
| 2003 | Josh | Kennedy | Hawthorn / Sydney |
| 2003 | Nick | Smith | Sydney |
| 2003 | Travis | Boak | Port Adelaide |
| 2003 | Robert | Eddy | St Kilda |
| 2002 | Travis | Cloke | Collingwood / Western Bulldogs |
| 2002 | Brett | Deledio | Richmond / Greater Westen Sydney |
| 2002 | Lynden | Dunn | Melbourne / Collingwood |
| 2002 | Marcus | Drum | Fremantle |
| 2002 | Ryan | Jackson | Carlton |
| 2002 | Joel | Selwood | Geelong |
| 2002 | Matthew | White | Richmond / Port Adelaide |
| 2002 | Michael | Newton | Melbourne |
| 2001 | Brock | McLean | Melbourne / Carlton |
| 2001 | Daniel | McConnell | West Coast / North Melbourne |
| 2001 | Tom | Murphy | Hawthorn |
| 2001 | Brent | Prismall | Geelong / Essendon |
| 2001 | Michael | Rischitelli | Brisbane / Gold Coast |
| 2001 | Brett | Stanton | Essendon |
| 2000 | Adam | Bentick | Carlton |
| 2000 | Luke | Brennan | Hawthorn / Sydney |
| 2000 | Brendon | Goddard | St Kilda |
| 2000 | Andrew | McQualter | St Kilda |
| 2000 | Steven | Salopek | Port Adelaide |
| 2000 | Kane | Tenace | Geelong |
| 2000 | Jobe | Watson | Essendon |
| 1999 | Luke | Ball | St Kilda / Collingwood |
| 1999 | Nick | Dal Santo | St Kilda |
| 1999 | Leigh | Fisher | St Kilda |
| 1999 | Luke | Hodge | Hawthorn |
| 1999 | Paul | Johnson | West Coast / Melbourne |
| 1999 | Matthew | Maguire | St Kilda / Brisbane |
| 1999 | Mark | McGough | Collingwood / St Kilda |
| 1999 | Luke | Mullins | Collingwood |
| 1998 | Ryan | Lonie | Collingwood |
| 1998 | Nathan | Lonie | Hawthorn / Port Adelaide |
| 1998 | Michael | Handby | Port Adelaide |
| 1998 | Sam | Hunt | Geelong |
| 1998 | Chris | Judd | West Coast / Carlton |
| 1998 | Ted | Richards | Essendon / Sydney |
| 1997 | Jason | Blake | St Kilda |
| 1997 | Mark | Bullen | Essendon |
| 1997 | Jonathan | Brown | Brisbane |
| 1997 | Damian | Cupido | Brisbane / Essendon |
| 1997 | Jeremy | Clayton | North Melbourne |
| 1997 | Mark | Dragicevic | Richmond |
| 1997 | Brendan | Fevola | Carlton / Brisbane |
| 1997 | Josh | Fraser | Collingwood / Gold Coast |
| 1997 | Brent | Guerra | Port Adelaide / St Kilda / Hawthorn |
| 1997 | David | Haynes | West Coast |
| 1997 | Chris | Lamb | Melbourne |
| 1997 | Cameron | Ling | Geelong |
| 1997 | Adam | Morgan | Port Adelaide / Western Bulldogs |
| 1997 | Luke | Penny | Western Bulldogs / St Kilda |
| 1997 | Dylan | Smith | North Melbourne / Fremantle |
| 1997 | Paul | Chapman | Geelong |
| 1997 | David | Spriggs | Geelong / Sydney |
| 1997 | Ezra | Poyas | Richmond / Melbourne |
| 1997 | Damien | Peverill | Essendon |
| 1997 | Ryan | O’Keefe | Sydney |
| 1997 | David | Teague | North Melbourne / Carlton |
| 1996 | Jude | Bolton | Sydney |
| 1996 | David | Clarke | Geelong / Carlton |
| 1996 | Adam | Goodes | Sydney |
| 1996 | Danny | Jacobs | Essendon / Hawthorn |
| 1996 | Kris | Massie | Carlton / Adelaide |
| 1996 | Brett | Moyle | St Kilda |
| 1996 | Billy | Nicholls | Hawthorn / Richmond |
| 1996 | Michael | Stevens | Port Adelaide |
| 1996 | Shannon | Watt | North Melbourne |
| 1995 | David | Antonowicz | West Coast |
| 1995 | Adrian | Cox | Hawthorn |
| 1995 | Trent | Croad | Hawthorn / Fremantle / Hawthorn |
| 1995 | Nick | Stevens | Port Adelaide / Carlton |
| 1995 | Craig | Jacotine | Collingwood |
| 1995 | Travis | Johnstone | Melbourne / Brisbane |
| 1995 | Matthew | Lucas | Western Bulldogs |
| 1995 | Luke | Power | Brisbane |
| 1995 | Chris | Tarrant | Collingwood / Fremantle / Collingwood |
| 1994 | Marcus | Barham | Collingwood |
| 1994 | Heath | Black | Fremantle / St Kilda / Fremantle |
| 1994 | Andrew | Eccles | Adelaide / Carlton |
| 1994 | Chris | Heffernan | Essendon / Melbourne / Essendon |
| 1994 | Rory | Hilton | Brisbane / Richmond |
| 1994 | John | Hynes | Carlton |
| 1994 | Mark | Johnson | Essendon / Fremantle |
| 1994 | Mark | Kinnear | Sydney |
| 1994 | Shane | O'Bree | Brisbane / Collingwood |
| 1994 | Frank | Raso | Collingwood |
| 1994 | Lance | Picioane | Adelaide / Hawthorn / North Melbourne |
| 1994 | Lance | Whitnall | Carlton |
| 1993 | Daniel | Bradshaw | Brisbane / Sydney |
| 1993 | Trent | Hoppner | Carlton |
| 1993 | Steven | King | Geelong / St Kilda |
| 1993 | Paul | Licuria | Sydney / Collingwood |
| 1993 | Matthew | Lloyd | Essendon |
| 1993 | Chad | Morrison | West Coast / Collingwood |
| 1993 | Dion | Miles | North Melbourne |
| 1993 | Emil | Parthenidis | Sydney |
| 1993 | Brent | Williams | Adelaide / Melbourne |
| 1993 | David | Wirrupunda | West Coast |
| 1992 | Tony | Brown | St Kilda |
| 1992 | Blake | Caracella | Essendon / Collingwood |
| 1992 | Matthew | Collins | Adelaide |
| 1992 | Ashley | Fernee | Adelaide |
| 1992 | Kane | Fraser | Hawthorn |
| 1992 | Shannon | Grant | Sydney / North Melbourne |
| 1992 | Daniel | Harford | Hawthorn / Carlton |
| 1992 | Darren | Hulme | Carlton |
| 1992 | Brad | Lloyd | Hawthorn |
| 1992 | Shawn | Lew-Fatt | Essendon / Geelong |
| 1992 | Chad | Liddell | Collingwood |
| 1992 | Josh | Mahoney | Collingwood / Footscray / Port Adelaide |
| 1992 | Mark | Nash | Adelaide |
| 1992 | Anthony | Rocca | Sydney / Collingwood |
| 1992 | Jeff | White | Fremantle / Melbourne |
| 1992 | Martin | Warry | Fitzroy / Collingwood |
| 1991 | Mark | Brebner | North Melbourne / Hawthorn |
| 1991 | Fraser | Gehrig | West Coast / St Kilda |
| 1991 | Glen | Gorman | North Melbourne |
| 1991 | Tyson | Lane | Footscray / Collingwood |
| 1991 | Nigel | Lappin | Brisbane |
| 1991 | Justin | Murphy | Richmond / Carlton / Geelong / Essendon |
| 1991 | Brad | Johnson | Footscray |
| 1991 | Stephen | Powell | Footscray / Melbourne / St Kilda |
| 1990 | John | Barnett | Hawthorn / North Melbourne / Collingwood |
| 1990 | Nathan | Chapman | Brisbane |
| 1990 | Sean | Charles | Melbourne / Carlton |
| 1990 | John | Georgiou | St Kilda |
| 1990 | Adrian | Whitehead | Carlton |
| 1989 | Daniel | Hargraves | Footscray / Fremantle |
| 1989 | Daniel | Morgan | Carlton / Essendon |
| 1989 | Mark | Mercuri | Essendon |
| 1989 | David | Neitz | Melbourne |
| 1989 | James | Thiesson | Richmond / Adelaide |
| 1989 | Shane | Watson | Collingwood |
| 1989 | Scott | West | Footscray |
| 1988 | Matthew | Allen | Carlton / Essendon |
| 1988 | Kent | Butcher | Geelong / Collingwood / Sydney |
| 1988 | Matthew | Croft | Footscray |
| 1988 | Jon | Hassall | Collingwood / Hawthorn |
| 1988 | Paul | Hopgood | Melbourne |
| 1988 | Anthony | Koutoufides | Carlton |
| 1988 | Jason | McCartney | Collingwood / Adelaide / North Melbourne |
| 1987 | Anthony | Banik | Richmond |
| 1987 | Leon | Cameron | Footscray / Richmond |
| 1987 | Glen | Kilpatrick | Essendon / Geelong |
| 1987 | Stuart | Maxfield | Richmond / Sydney |
| 1987 | David | Mensch | Geelong |
| 1987 | Andrew | Wills | Geelong / Fremantle |
| 1987 | Chris | Barrett | Geelong |
| 1986 | Domenic | Berry | Hawthorn |
| 1986 | Jayson | Daniels | Sydney / St Kilda |
| 1986 | Aldo | Dipetta | St Kilda / Sydney |
| 1986 | Gordon | Fode | St Kilda |
| 1986 | Mark | Neeld | Geelong |
| 1986 | Jose | Romero | North Melbourne / Footscray |
| 1986 | Corey | Young | Richmond / West Coast |
| 1985 | Nathan | Burke | St Kilda |
| 1985 | Paul | Broderick | Fitzroy / Richmond |
| 1985 | Ron | James | Footscray |
| 1985 | Andrew | Johnston | Essendon / Fitzroy |
| 1985 | Terry | Keyes | Collingwood / Richmond |
| 1985 | Brendan | McCormack | Fitzroy / Brisbane |
| 1985 | Andrew | Phillips | Carlton |
| 1985 | Barry | Stanfield | Footscray / Adelaide |
| 1985 | Barry | Young | Richmond / Essendon |
| 1984 | John | Barnes | Essendon / Geelong / Essendon |
| 1984 | Sean | Denham | Geelong / Essendon |
| 1984 | Greg | Faull | Collingwood |
| 1984 | David | Flood | Essendon |
| 1984 | Robert | Scott | Geelong / North Melbourne |
| 1984 | Peter | Whyte | Geelong |
| 1983 | Darren | Denneman | Geelong / Sydney |
| 1983 | Michael | Gurrie | Geelong |
| 1983 | Garry | Hocking | Geelong |
| 1983 | John | Peter-Budge | St Kilda |
| 1983 | Barry | Stoneham | Geelong |
| 1982 | Dean | Bailey | Essendon / Melbourne / Port Adelaide |
| 1982 | Mark | Bayes | Sydney |
| 1982 | Simon | Clark | Richmond |
| 1982 | Adrian | Gleeson | Carlton |
| 1982 | Ben | Ingleton | St Kilda |
| 1982 | Ricky | Jackson | Richmond / Melbourne |
| 1982 | Gary | Lyon | Melbourne |
| 1982 | Alan | McKellar | Richmond / Sydney / Footscray |
| 1982 | Geoff | Parker | Essendon |
| 1981 | Gary | Cameron | Geelong |
| 1981 | Peter | Dean | Carlton |
| 1981 | Mil | Hanna | Carlton |
| 1981 | John | Fidge | Melbourne / Brisbane |
| 1981 | Darren | Steele | North Melbourne |
| 1980 | Peter | Banfield | Essendon / St Kilda |
| 1980 | Glen | Dickson | Richmond |
| 1980 | Patrick | Foy | Sydney |
| 1980 | Dean | Holden | Sydney / North Melbourne |
| 1980 | Steve | Hocking | Geelong |
| 1980 | Gary | Pert | Fitzroy / Collingwood |
| 1980 | Paul | Salmon | Essendon / Hawthorn / Essendon |
| 1980 | Dan | Morgan | Geelong |
| 1980 | Nicholas | Walsh | Essendon |
| 1979 | Andrew | Bews | Geelong |
| 1979 | Dermott | Brereton | Hawthorn / Sydney / Collingwood |
| 1979 | Tim | Darcy | Geelong |
| 1979 | Dean | Herbert | Richmond / St Kilda |
| 1979 | Garry | Johns | Geelong |
| 1979 | Peter | Maloni | Sydney |
| 1979 | Trevor | Poole | Richmond / Geelong |
| 1979 | Ray | Sarcevic | Geelong |
| 1979 | Steve | Wallis | Footscray |
| 1978 | Adrian | Battiston | Melbourne / Sydney |
| 1978 | Gary | Booth | St Kilda |
| 1978 | Damien | Christiansen | Geelong |
| 1978 | Phil | Egan | Richmond |
| 1978 | Mark | Eustice | Essendon / Sydney / Richmond |
| 1978 | Kevin | Hughes | North Melbourne |
| 1978 | Spiros | Kourkoumelis | Carlton / St Kilda |
| 1977 | Greg | Williams | Geelong / Sydney / Carlton |
| 1977 | Ian | Rickman | Footscray |
| 1977 | Stephen | Reynoldson | Geelong / Brisbane |
| 1977 | Michael | Sculze | Geelong |
| 1977 | Dale | Smyth | Geelong |
| 1976 | Steven | Wright | South Melbourne |
| 1976 | Glen | Hawker | Essendon / Carlton |
| 1976 | Phillip | Maddock | Geelong |
| 1976 | Tim | Watson | Essendon |
| 1975 | Wayne | Harmes | Carlton |
| 1975 | Peter | Thorne | Melbourne |
| 1975 | Tom | Floyd | Geelong / Collingwood |
| 1975 | Craig | Dowsett | Geelong |
| 1974 | Jim | Buckley | Carlton |
| 1974 | Peter | Fitzpatrick | Carlton / St Kilda |
| 1974 | Russell | Koehler | Geelong |
| 1974 | David | McKay | Carlton |
| 1974 | Paul | Norwood | South Melbourne / St Kilda |
| 1974 | Wayne | Primmer | Essendon |
| 1974 | Ken | Sheldon | Carlton / St Kilda |
| 1974 | Michael | Wright | South Melbourne |
| 1973 | Terry | Bright | Geelong |
| 1973 | Leigh | Carlson | Collingwood / Fitzroy |
| 1973 | Ken | Mansfield | Essendon |
| 1972 | Stephen | Robins | Essendon |
| 1972 | Alan | Edwards | Richmond / Collingwood / Footscray |
| 1972 | Noel | Jenkinson | Richmond |
| 1972 | Robert | Steven | Geelong |
| 1971 | Jeffrey | Gieschen | Footscray |
| 1971 | Roy | Ramsay | North Melbourne / Essendon |
| 1971 | Mark | Sarau | St Kilda |
| 1971 | Steven | Smith | Melbourne |
| 1971 | Kelvin | Templeton | Footscray / Melbourne |
| 1971 | Don | Whitford | Fitzroy |
| 1970 | Howard | Staehr | Essendon |
| 1970 | Phillip | Manassa | Collingwood |
| 1970 | Gregory | Bell | Essendon |
| 1969 | Robert | Lamb | Richmond / South Melbourne |
| 1969 | Steve | Lunn | Geelong / Footscray |
| 1969 | Greg | Wood | Melbourne |
| 1968 | Wes | Barrot | Richmond / Collingwood |
| 1968 | Russell | Davies | St Kilda |
| 1968 | Kelvin | Matthews | Hawthorn / Geelong |
| 1968 | Leigh | Matthews | Hawthorn |
| 1968 | Andrew | Lynch | Geelong / Richmond |
| 1968 | Paul | Sarah | Geelong / Richmond |
| 1968 | Mark | Browne | Geelong |
| 1967 | Lloyd | Burgman | Melbourne |
| 1967 | Roger | McHardy | Footscray |
| 1967 | William | Nalder | Richmond |
| 1967 | Harry | Skreja | Footscray |
| 1966 | Rob | Peterson | North Melbourne |
| 1965 | Bruce | Brown | Melbourne / Essendon |
| 1965 | Steven | Hoffman | South Melbourne / Footscray |
| 1965 | Mark | Slater | Collingwood |
| 1964 | Jeffery | Pitts | Collingwood |
| 1964 | John | Stephens | St Kilda |
| 1964 | Peter | Pettigrew | Collingwood |
| 1964 | Geoff | Blethyn | Essendon |
| 1964 | Ian | Wallace | Footscray |
| 1964 | Ron | McFarlane | Essendon |
| 1964 | Des | Campbell | Melbourne |
| 1964 | Ricky | Browne | Geelong |
| 1963 | Robert | Stevens | Collingwood |
| 1963 | Sid | Catlin | Melbourne / South Melbourne |
| 1963 | Trevor | Wilson | Richmond / Footscray |
| 1963 | Gary | Hardeman | Melbourne |
| 1963 | Barry | Grinter | Essendon / Richmond |
| 1962 | Geoff | Smith | Hawthorn |
| 1962 | Ken | Osborne | Melbourne |
| 1962 | Chris | Aitken | Melbourne |
| 1962 | George | Johnstone | Melbourne |
| 1962 | Greg | Perry | Essendon |
| 1962 | Derek | King | St Kilda |
| 1962 | Norm | Mitchell | Footscray |
| 1961 | John | Williams | Essendon / Collingwood |
| 1961 | Ray | Smith | Essendon / Melbourne |
| 1961 | Kelvin | Clarke | Melbourne |
| 1961 | Bill | Walford | Richmond / Fitzroy |
| 1961 | Trevor | Dawson | Fitzroy |
| 1960 | Ricky | Watt | Collingwood |
| 1960 | Robert | Lane | Carlton |
| 1960 | Neville | Stone | Melbourne |
| 1960 | Ian | Payne | Essendon |
| 1959 | Carlton | Ditterich | St Kilda / Melbourne |
| 1959 | Bob | Lynch | Fitzroy |
| 1959 | Peter | Hogan | Richmond |
| 1959 | Jim | Leitch | Melbourne |
| 1958 | David | Albiston | Hawthorn |
| 1958 | Peter | Brain | South Melbourne |
| 1958 | Gordon | Dann | South Melbourne |
| 1958 | Graeme | Watson | Melbourne |
| 1958 | Bruce | Bentley | Carlton |
| 1958 | Dennis | Bartley | St Kilda |
| 1958 | Ray | Groom | Melbourne |
| 1957 | Ross | Smith | St Kilda |
| 1957 | Ron | O'Brien | Richmond |
| 1957 | Tony | Polinelli | Geelong |
| 1956 | Alf | Chapman | South Melbourne |
| 1956 | Ray | Walker | Footscray |
| 1955 | Larry | Rowe | Richmond |
| 1955 | Graeme | Beissel | Essendon |
| 1955 | John | Bradbury | Footscray |
| 1955 | Charlie | Evans | Footscray / South Melbourne |
| 1954 | Not Known | -- | -- |
| 1953 | John E | Hoiles | Footscray |
| 1953 | Bob | Skilton | South Melbourne |
| 1952 | Ken | Dean | North Melbourne |
| 1952 | John | Kelton | South Melbourne |
| 1951 | Fred | Macquire | North Melbourne |
| 1951 | Stuart | Lennie | St Kilda |
| 1950 | Frank | Johnson | Footscray / Fitzroy |
| 1950 | Ken | Hedt | Collingwood |
| 1950 | Bryan | King | St Kilda |
| 1950 | Don | Matthews | South Melbourne |
| 1949 | Not Known | -- | -- |
| 1948 | Martin | Davis | Richmond |
| 1948 | Ron G | Smith | Fitzroy |
